Adjustments
I just
realized that I have been living here in Cairo for more than three years. This
is a long time for someone who never intended to live or work
here. With all the uncertainty in the air about Egypt’s future, one
wonders how much longer I and others like me can thrive here. But rather than
speculate about the future (again), I have decided to reflect on my past and
share a few of the adjustments I made as a dancer. There were many,
because belly dance outside of Egypt is a totally different animal than belly
dance inside Egypt. There were adjustments in technicality, musicality,
and even physicality. There were adjustments in music selection and music
understanding, costuming and audience. And there were changes in attitude,
ethics and comportment.
Technique
Perhaps
one of my biggest initial challenges as a foreign student of Egyptian dance was
learning proper technique. Egyptian technique is much more subtle,
nuanced, and intricate than what most of us learn back home. Movements are
smaller and more precise, more controlled and more meaningful. Upon studying dance
here, I had to unlearn everything I thought I knew and start from
scratch. For example, in the US, I learned to do everything
in plié. Shimmy in plié. Hip drops in plié. Figure 8’s in
plié. I never noticed how bent my knees were until I came here and
Egyptians pointed it out. Not only do bent knees look bad, but they
prevent us from making our hip movements as powerful as possible. I have since
straightened up and become a stickler for straight knees, as anyone who has
ever taken class with me can attest.
No sooner had I replaced my American technique with Egyptian vocabulary than I met my next challenge: slowing down. Non-Egyptian dancers have a tendency to do too much too fast too soon. If we don’t cram all the moves we know into one piece of music, if we don’t hit every single doom and tak, we feel as though we’re not doing the music justice. This isn’t necessarily the case. Less really is more. Slowing down is probably THE single most valuable piece of advice I have heard in all my years here, and it came from none other than Sara Farouk. I consider Sara one of Cairo’s best kept secrets. She is the organizer of the Randa Kamel of Course intensive held twice a year here in Cairo, and an assistant to costume designer Eman Zaki. More than that, Sara is one of the best belly dance instructors I’ve encountered, and a really good friend. She has a talent for spotting all of your belly dance flaws and correcting them. Now, every time I go on stage, I think of Sara and make a point of slowing down and feeling the music, no matter what I’m doing.
The
Show
These
were some of the technical adjustments I had to make as a student relearning
how to belly dance in Egypt. When I finally found a stage, however, I had other
things to think about. For starters, the shows here are longer. A
typical belly dance performance at any hotel, boat or wedding runs between 45
minutes to an hour. They are not the 15 to 20 minute gigs
we do back home in one costume. Each show is divided into 2 to 5 sections,
depending on the performance format of the venue. The dancer changes her
costume for each section, and performs to a different sub-genre of Egyptian
music. For example, in the first set, the dancer will usually dance to an
instrumental entrance piece, which is what Egyptians call the mejance,
and followed by one or two classics. This takes anywhere between ten and
twenty minutes. She then changes her costume and dances her second set for
another ten to twenty minutes. Typically, the second set involves some
type of folklore and shaabi music. Whether it’s saidi, iskanderani,
Nubian or khaligi, the dancer costumes appropriately. For the third set,
dancers usually wear another belly dance costume and continue with things like sharqi,
baladi, and finish with a drum solo. Some performances deviate from
this, but this is generally the standard belly dance show format in
Egypt.
Because the shows are longer and more comprehensive, I had to really brush up on all types of folklore. I could not rely on all the (con)fusion I learned back home, because things like wings, fan veils, swords, and candle trays just don’t cut it here. Egyptian audiences want to watch you dance, not do circus acts. This was actually a relief for me, as I never really enjoyed dancing with props.
Music
Music
selection was another big one for me. Because the Middle Eastern community
in New York is diverse, I would dance to Egyptian, Lebanese, Syrian and Turkish
music all in one set. In Egypt, however, people’s taste in music is well,
Egyptian. Unless it’s George Wassouf or or someone like Melhem Barakat, I
learned not to deviate too far from the standard Egyptian classics that all
Egyptians know and love. I also learned that I really need to understand song
lyrics. Not so that I can play charades on stage, but so that I can be
emotionally in tune with the music.
Physical Appearance
Physically,
I’ve also undergone some changes… for the better, I like to think. For the
first two years that I lived here, I was sickly skinny. You could see my
ribs, and I had no rear. This was odd, being that I had always been
slightly on the round side. It’s not that I was on a diet or even exercising
that much. I was, however, under a whole lot of stress. Between
adjusting to the culture and constantly dealing with selfish, narcissistic
types, I entered into a depressive slump that affected not only my weight, but
my entire outlook on life. Luckily, I was able to make the changes I
needed in order to restore my health, happiness, sanity, and love
handles. Not to mention my big old butt….
…which is having a difficult time squeezing into costumes these days. (Thank God I live within a three-mile radius of Eman Zaki and can have costumes custom made!). Any other girl would be freaking out if she gained the 25 pounds that I have gained since moving here, but not me. I’m proud of them. They serve me well on stage. I kind of like how every sharp movement I do now has an unintentional shimmy reverb. Not to mention, Egyptians like a little more junk in the trunk. So it all works out.
Which brings me to my next point. Dancers here are encouraged to select the costumes that flatter their curves the most. That means tight-fitting lycra skirts that trace every dimple and cellulite deposit on your thighs and butt. Sexy. The more traditional chiffon bra and belt numbers are no longer in fashion. Nobody wears them here. Ever. Nobody does fringe that much either. This all came as a shock to me when I first arrived here, because most of us wear these traditional bedlas back home. Except for the lack of fringe, I have taken quite a liking to the more modern costumes, even if they do define my thigh dimples every now and then. With lycra, the possibilities are endless. From newspaper-print lycra to heavily-sequined spandex, stretch fabric has stretched our imaginations to the extremes. Hence, fabric shopping has become a regular part of my weekly routine. This is why I now own more than 30 pieces of fabric, all waiting to be transformed into gorgeous costumes.
Attitude
Alongside
all the changes I made in technique, music selection, and costuming, the
biggest adjustment I have been making is one of consciousness. I no longer
belly dance. I am a belly dancer. Meaning, belly dance isn’t
just a hobby I do on the weekends to make a few extra bucks. It is my full-time
job now, and it pays my bills.
I am also no longer a one-woman production the way I was in New York. Back home, I would show up for my gigs, CD in hand, ready to dance for fifteen minutes and do it all over again at the next venue. It was just me, myself, and I. Here, I am part of a larger team of musicians, managers, agents, and male dancers… you know, those young guys who do the cheesy YMCA-type movements at the beginning of any belly dance show? They also share the stage with me when I perform any type of folklore. Because we interact with each other while dancing saidi or Alexandrian, we actually have to conduct rehearsals from time to time. This is always fun(ny).
Though I am technically part of a team of musicians an ddancer, the concept of teamwork does not always apply the way it would outside of Egypt. For example, Egyptian dancers see (and often treat) their musicians as inferiors. As tools. Foreign dancers are taught to do the same. Unnecessary interaction with the band is strongly discouraged, which means there is little to no camaraderie amongst coworkers even though we see each other every day. I’m sure each dancer’s situation varies somewhat, and there are examples of dancers breaking the rules, but generally this is the dynamic between a belly dancer and her band. I personally try to keep things a little less formal and more humane, but this doesn’t always work out.
The relationships amongst dancers here is similarly uncordial. Again, there are exceptions to this, but for the most part, there’s no sisterhood between belly dancers the way (we think) there is back home. This is because there are fewer work opportunities than there are dancers, so dancers tend to view each other as competition, not as friends. Though this holds true around the world, the situation doesn’t seem to be as cut throat as it is in Egypt. In New York City, for example, most of the dancers were (and still are) friends. We would hang out, work with each other, drink with each other, take class together, etc. Here, dancers generally avoid one another. If they interact, it’s usually in a negative, destructive way, such as reporting each other to the belly dance police, or stealing each other’s costumes. Both of these things happened to me. This is unfortunate, considering we have so much in common, but I was warned about this when I first moved to Egypt. Even though I had no intention of performing, my Egyptian dance teachers would always tell me to avoid making friends with dancers. I do see the wisdom in this, however there are a couple of dancers whom I respect and admire greatly, and with whom I stay on friendly terms.
Contract
The
fact that I am now contracted means that my job imposes certain responsibilities
on me. Kind of like any other ‘normal’
job would. For example, no matter how sick I am, I can’t just not show up
for work, or send a replacement and hope they like her. I also have to
constantly update my costume wardrobe. In short, I have to be on top of my
game, because in Egypt, the belly dancer is the reason for the evening. Egyptians
and tourists go to venues that feature belly dancing specifically to watch the
dancer. Not like in the US, where people go to restaurants to eat, and ‘oh
by the way’ there’s a belly dancer. When you’re a ‘by-the-way’ belly
dancer, you can get away with not doing your best—your audience is more
interested in that chicken on the plate anyway. In Egypt, all eyes are on
the belly dancer for the complete duration of her performance. So, there is
more pressure for her to be at her best (assuming she cares). In the end,
however, it is totally rewarding. Both Egyptian and foreign audiences appreciate
a good show. In fact, it is quite common for audience members to
treat good dancers as celebrities… running after them before they disappear
into the changing room, begging to be photographed with them, kissing them, or hiring
them for so-and-so’s wedding.
I will never forget my very first show in Egypt two years ago. It was at a remote Red Sea resort two hours away from Cairo. Before I could even finish taking a bow, I had almost the entire audience up on stage with me—kids, moms, dads—kissing my sweating face and pulling me alongside them to take pictures. Never before had I seen an audience react to a belly dancer this way before. I was overwhelmed by the love. At first, I thought maybe it was just this particular audience that was particularly warm, but the more I performed, the more I encountered similar reactions. I’ve heard other popular dancers in Cairo relate similar experiences as well, which means Egyptians really appreciate a good show.
When people ask me what is keeping me in Egypt all this time, I answer, this. Knowing that I have made people happy with my performance. Knowing that audiences truly appreciate my art. Because other than great audiences, mostly everything else that comes with being a belly dancer in Cairo is some type of nastiness. Indeed, one of the mysteries of the universe is how an artist makes so many people happy could be considered a hell-bound prostitute by those same individuals. It’s a real mindfuck, let me tell you… feeling like a sinner and a celebrity all at the same time.
One thing is for sure: I am neither a sinner nor a celebrity, but I have learned to accept that other people see me as such. More importantly, I am a different dancer than the one I used to be in New York, and a different dancer than the one I will be in two more years… because each night on the stage is a learning experience as much as it is a gift.
Hey there,
ReplyDeleteI love all your posts but please please please change the background, its killing my eyes.
Have fun dancing ;)
I'll take that into consideration. :)
DeleteHey Anonymous,
DeleteIn the meantime, or if Luna decides to keep the awesome pink-zebra-rhinestone-flowers concept, you can always just go up to your browser toolbar, select "view", select "page style" and click "no style", to see all the great content with little-to-no eyeball death :)
Wonderful insight and great advice for all dancers!
ReplyDeleteThanks Victoria :)
DeleteNot that I meant to tell you what to do, but don't change a thing you're doing Luna. ;-)
ReplyDeleteGotcha. :) Appreciate the encouragement.
DeleteThanks, I love the honesty!
ReplyDeleteHey Luna ..
ReplyDeleteI Saw U Dancing last night...At Hotel.. I was at wedding last night... U r So Gorgeous [♥] Ahmed Mahrous..One of Ur New fans
Hi Ahmed, What a coincidence that you saw me dancing! Thanks for your compliment. Hope to see you again in the future. :)
Delete:D where ?
DeleteGreat post - I loved reading about the transition in your personal dance and outlook. Thanks for it!
ReplyDeleteRaksanna
Thanks Raksanna, I think I published that too fast though... I had more to say ahhaha :) Oh well, next time. Looking forward to reading more of your blog.
Deletetouching! :)
ReplyDeletexox
Luna, I am so inspired by all the information you provide. I just love knowing that I don't need to be skinny like a supermodel or perform "circus acts" with props and I can rest assure that I am being authentic.
ReplyDeleteThank you!!
I was so sucked into your story. I hardly ever read long content all the way through but this really captured my attention. Very very interesting to learn how belly dancing in Cairo is, especially from an American's perspective and how you had to adapt. Thanks for sharing! Aesera
ReplyDeleteThanks for reading Aesera. :) Glad you enjoyed it!
DeleteA very nice article.
ReplyDeleteVery honest and informative. Being an Egyptian myself, I always wondered what makes Egyptian belly dancers look and dance differently than foreigners. Your article highlighted some of the points that I noticed, but couldn't point them as clear as you did through your deep observation and attention to details.
Perhaps you should think of writing a book about your Egyptian adventures and writing not only about belly dancing, but also your observation of the people, the society and politics in Egypt. I think your background and political studies (I think you are Harvard university graduate yourself?) would be of great benefit.
I'll make sure to see you performing next time with my wife and four kids!
Hi Tamer, thanks for writing. :) I'm glad I was able to clarify some things, but I'm sure there's a lot more I'm missing. So yes, I'm a Harvard grad, and I do intend to write a book one day--not just about the dance, but about my experience in Egypt, as you suggest. There's so much to share, but I'm too busy now to do it. That's why I keep the blog instead. :) But yes I'd love to have you and your family at my show. Do let me know whenever you want to come.
DeleteBest,
Luna
Really great information. I too have a difficult time staying interested in blogs... I saw this pop up on Bhuz and actually ran to your site to read the rest. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteKhuzama
Hi Khuzama,
DeleteJust saw this comment, so sorry for not responding earlier. Thanks for writing, and for reading my blog. Your comments and insights are always welcome. :)
Hey LUNA! it was great to meet you in Gainesville ( I was vending) I wish I took the workshop it looked SO AWESOME!
ReplyDeleteI love this article! I hope to travel to Egypt soon and would love to be as appreciated one day when I perform =) Thanks for the blog!
Hi Anais,
DeleteIt was great meeting you in Gainesville too! Thanks for writing, and definitely let me know when you come to Cairo. :D
Great post! Thanks for sharing with such honesty and humor. You're a brave woman! :) Loved the con"fusion" comment, because it's true! I live in NY and teach at gyms, and I do have a blend of Turkish, Egyptian, and who knows what else in my technique :P And the shaking to each doom and tek! And yes, now a lot of dancers are great to each other here, but it was probably similar to Egypt's attitude way back when, because I saw it in the old-school teachers' attitude (don't dance with that person, don't take their classes, don't this or that). So interesting, maybe that's where they got it from. The curves part, I've heard that here too.. everything becomes a little easier ;) The knees comment was especially interesting. My two best instructors had the same discrepancy, one always cued very bent knees, and the other insisted: don't bend them! :P I try to do and teach what's most comfortable for the joints and gets more muscle work which tends to be knees bent. But who knows, maybe when you're in NY I can take a workshop and I'll realize I could be wrong! Funny, how as you get older you realize the framework (of not just dance)you've been working with may not have been true/correct, all this time ;)
ReplyDeleteAnd thank you for the no circus performance acts! I always felt slightly inadequate that besides a veil, and an ocassional cane at best, nothing else came easy to me :P
Hi, I just saw this comment now. Thanks for reading and posting. It seems like we're on the same page when it comes to many things in dance. :) About "right" and "wrong," a good friend of mine advised me that when I teach, I shouldn't speak in terms of wrong and right, in terms of stylistic choices. So bent knees, for example, are not "wrong," they're just not Egyptian style. They're American cabaret style. I personally DO believe there is a right way to dance and a wrong way, however you don't want to get people angry with you for saying that. :)
DeleteThe paradox you highlight about being seen as a sinner and celebrity is extremely fascinating. It seems as if this paradox is somewhat implicit to the Egyptian belly dance world...have you thought more deeply about why this is or maybe asked Egyptians themselves about it? Has this historically been the case? Is it getting worse, better, or stayed the same?
ReplyDeleteHi, and thanks for your comment and questions. I think the sinner/celebrity paradox has existed for centuries, and is probably as old as the dance. The dance as a performance art, that is. Without asking Egyptians, I think it's because the human in us (i.e. the heart and soul) loves music and dance, while the brainwashed parts of us tell us it's sinful. I don't think it's getting worse or better. It's something that's always been and always will be.
Delete